Statement on the UK Supreme Court Decision – For Women Scotland v Scottish Ministers and the Interim Guidance from the Equality and Human Rights Commission
As a charity dedicated to supporting the LGBTQIA+ community, we have long stood by our trans and gender-diverse siblings – individuals who continue to face heightened scrutiny, misinformation, and exclusion.
The recent ruling by the UK Supreme Court, and the subsequent interim guidance from the Equality and Human Rights Commission, has created serious concern within our community. The decision – focusing on the legal definition of “woman” in equality legislation – has profound implications for trans rights, and particularly for the recognition of trans women under the law.
While the court was careful to say this was “not a win for either side”, its interpretation significantly narrows legal protections for trans individuals. What we are left with is a legal framework that, however well-intentioned, fails to reflect the lived realities of trans and gender-diverse people across the UK. It also opens the door for misunderstanding and misapplication, which risks harm not only to trans people, but to anyone whose identity or appearance does not conform to rigid societal expectations of gender.
Already, we are hearing reports of increased hostility – not only toward trans people, but also towards lesbian and cisgender women who are being wrongly targeted. This creates an environment of fear and exclusion, undermining the very idea of what equality the law is supposed to uphold. Intersex individuals too, remain largely invisible in this conversation, further marginalised by decisions that don’t reflect the complexity of human diversity.
We believe in a United Kingdom that is compassionate, fair, and inclusive. We reject any attempt to divide or diminish our community. Trans rights are human rights – and recognising someone’s gender identity is a matter of dignity, respect, and empathy. This isn’t about reductive biology, it never has been. It is about respect and value as human beings, something we feel is being eroded by judgements like this, and the arguments used to validate inaccurate and uninformed claims by a minority of people. We can and must do better, not only for trans and gender diverse rights, but the humanity we British are known for.
Now is the time to act. We urge everyone who values equality to:
- Write to your MP to express concern and ask for action to protect trans rights.
- Support petitions that call for change in the law to ensure no one is left behind.
- Donate to charities and grassroots groups working tirelessly to support trans people.
- Speak up with kindness and courage – especially when others are silenced.
